Nomination Queries #3

[mod63]

Please see previous posts if you nominated Merlin, Fire Emblem: Three Houses or Sherlock Holmes.

• Nominator of 100 Girlfriends, we have approved nominations with "Rentarou Family" because there seems to be a shared understanding in the fandom of who is referred to by that term, but please have realistic expectations about how many characters you can expect to appear in fic or art written for this tag; if you are dead set on seeing specific people, you might want to nominate them.


• Nominator of The Lighthouse, we're sorry for the confusion with our previous query, but since the fandom seems to typically call that character Ephraim Winslow we've approved the tag as Ephraim Winslow.


• Nominator of Love & Legends, we can accept your nomination as-is but please be aware that we won't permit recipients to request or DNW a specific gender of main character if the tag just says Main Character.


• Nominators of Dragon Age, similarly, we can accept your Warden nominations but if you want a particular Warden backstory please bake it into the tag. There's also a "M!Alistair/Morrigan" nomination that needs to be fixed.


• Nominators of All Elite Wrestling and Ring of Honor, we approved the latter but then noticed that Bryan Danielson was nominated in both, and on looking up the fandoms, it seems like ROH got sold to AEW and most of the other wrestlers nominated under ROH also wrestle(d) for AEW. Mods have very little grasp of how continuity works in wrestling; are these separate fandoms or one fandom?


• Nominators of Percy Jackson, in a previous year we approved all Percy Jackson bookverse tags under "Percy Jackson and the Olympians - Rick Riordan" even though that tag technically doesn't encompass Heroes of Olympus/Trials of Apollo, because the "All Media Types" metatag that encompasses all of those books also encompasses the films, TV, and musical. Is this acceptable, or would you prefer a tag that is non-canonical but clear like Percy Jackson Bookverse?


• Nominators of Buffy and Mass Effect Trilogy, do you have feelings/opinions about us approving the noms as-is or approving them as "Buffyverse" and/or "Mass Effect (Video Games)" to catch potential nominations of Angel and Andromeda under the same fandom?